Pihole vs opendns reddit. Disclaimer : I use Pihole with NextDNS as the resolver.

Pihole vs opendns reddit Pihole "directly competes" with Adguard Home or Blocky, those would be the direct comparison. I am thinking of replacing pihole with pfBlockerNG. Check out DNS-O-Matic for details. Make sure the underlying os for the pihole talks directly to external dns servers to avoid boot up issues. Welcome to /r/Linux! This is a community for sharing news about Linux, interesting developments and press. I could do all this myself as you say but for the hassle it would be and how reliable OpenDNS has been it's not worth self hosting IMHO. I have used a lot of different DNS filtering and Ad Blocking solutions like Pihole, AdguardHome, AdGuard DNS, CloudFlare, OpenDNS, etc. 254 (my AT&T Router?) Set my PiHole DHCP range from 192. e Pihole set to OpenDNS and Cloudflare yet my resolve. Last issue is that I cannot access the web interface of pihole from my Windows 10 client using pi. Pihole interface is great and it has got several other features which openwrt adblock doesn't provide. The pihole, since it cannot be used as a resolver and needs a forward DNS resolver, sends the requests to a local unbound which is the last step and resolves the actual DBS request that cannot be satisfied from the internal Dnsmasq or was blocked by pihole So: client -> Dnsmasq -> pihole -> unbound -> root DNS servers Jan 30, 2024 · What's the difference between a local dns server, unbound, remote ones like google's 8. if i replace the DNS from OpenDNS to the . I run pihole with OpenDNS. Newbie experience - Firewalla Gold vs. 8) - why? Are these suppose to be different? No mention, by Asus, of the Conditional Forwarding issue that can arise if one has it enabled in the PiHole and uses PiHole in the router WAN fields. 0ms) My Pi-Hole is actually forwarding to opendns as upstream DNS (not using DoH yet). It's running in a docker container and my router DNS points to the Synology local IP. Pi is hardwired to the network and my Wi-Fi is provided by Eero pro system, which hands out Pihole as a primary DNS server and OpenDNS as a secondary (because I have only one Pi, I wanted to, in case the Pi freezes or something, to be able to tell my wife to unplug the Pi or something and devices can keep working by reaching a secondary DNS I can't speak for unbound vs opendns, but on my pi 3, I think unbound is actually faster than not using it and using pihole for all DNS stuff, if that makes sense. Think of this, AdGuard could potentially make a site non working, with the Pihole this is easily fixable (whitelists). When you set up the Pi-Hole package you are given the option of choosing the upstream DNS server that you would like to use for the Pi-Hole's lookups. And I was hoping it could be updated soon to reflect that OpenDNS also supports the feature since every other DNS service listed under the toggle in Pi-hole is one on the default list. My experience is in Network Forensics and Incident Response forensics (so not Dead disc or full disc forensics). Best of both worlds PiHole gets my vote. It's quite good, but forget privacy - OpenDNS (Cisco) can see your DNS requests. 8, & cloudflare's 1. If you are happy with the way the complete solution works - no matter which it is - use the one you like. It is running great. dnscrypt-proxy cache I am running pihole(s) on tiny pi zero w machine with dnscrypt-proxy cache. 222. I picked pihole because I liked the idea of pairing pihole with unbound. So the question is, would I gain any benefit by making the switch over to pihole vs my current hosts/privoxy setup? I have quite a few devices on the network, although not as many as others. I think it is the best of all worlds for people using a PiHole on the LAN but DHCP on the PfSense. Click "Edit" on the lan you'd like to direct to pihole. I'm having a hard time sorting through them to know which is the best practice and what the advantages/disadvantages of each are. Cloudflare's DNS: 1. 1 and 1. Configuring the router to use it as your upstream DNS. I always thought that the secondary DNS is a fall-back solution; only used in case the primary DNS fails. I have yet to have it work well. I figured since I'd have to use the command line to get multiple DHCP scopes working in PiHole I might as well use something that's wholly CLI configured. PfSense WAN DNS server is pointing to OpenDNS servers. This way, all DNS is over TLS and the availability of the pihole does not effect DNS resolution on my opnSense box. Using NextDNS for my mobile connections I liked the effectivness as well as the UI. I swapped my pihole's upstream to OpenDNS for DNS leak test, and was surprised to find that Cloudflare was contacted once. But now I login into the Pihole admin page and don't see any traffic other than itself going through the pihole. I have a raspberry pi 4 running PiHole, which is set to use OpenDNS as it's upstream resolver. I have found a way to get the pihole server up on using my windows PC but it isn't working the same. Disclaimer: Long comment is long. com in my query log. 0 prefix before web address then it doesn’t work. There you copy the RAW link from the table (right click on RAW, copy) and add it to Pihole. The NAS is always on and I repurposed an old Raspberry Pi to run Pi Hole. I deployed Umbrella (native, not FTD) for a 50,000 user organisation. Straight out of the box some sites that loaded slow now fly. 15 as static) my router is pointing to OpenDNS ip addresses. OpenDNS has a number of methods for automatically updating the IP associated with your account. I know adding every DNSSEC capable provider out there would be overly complicated and a lot of work. Biggest advantage of the Pihole is, that you have full control over everything including blocklists. I do like the flexibility with the categories for blocking sites etc Hi. We exist to provide a safe haven for all followers of Jesus Christ to discuss God, Jesus, the Bible, and information relative to our beliefs, and to provide non-believers a place to ask questions about Christianity as explained in the scriptures, without fear of mockery or debasement. com. com for both with port 853. I've had various router-based ad block solutions, compared to pihole, they are archaic beasts, they work, but I'd never go back to them over a pihole. OpenDNS is used for content filtering. You can white list or black list other domains as required. And then having your openDNS server as the output in pihole. However, prior to using pi-hole, I used Asus Merlin's DNSFilter to set the kids' devices to OpenDNS to block unsavory sites, and other sites not suitable for their age. So I decided to disable Lighttpd and installed nginx and PHP 7. Unbound caches DNS like pihole does with dnsmasq, but it will automatically renew the cache as the TTL runs out so it will always be able to serve up cached DNS responses. A community for sharing and promoting free/libre and open-source software (freedomware) on the Android platform. Modify your PiHole DNS to use only a custom DNS server and set that to the LAN IP of your PfSense. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now I'm curious what other pihole users use as their upstream dns and what settings they use as well Other things you may run on your PC do not benefit from them. I wasn't home but my wife called me complaining the Internet wasn't working. PiHole is not a web content filter, it is an Ad blocker. But that's all part of the fun; and, with the help of searching Reddit and Google, I'm sure I'll figure it all out :) I'm just curious if I'll be better off leaving the Pi-hole alone, or if it's perfectly fine to shove PiVPN down the Pi-hole without any consequences. To Clarify a little more, here is the OpenDNS has a dashboard where you can see all your queries block ones you don't like. The main advantages of using NextDNS over Pi-hole® are: Ease of installation and maintenance. It's not a specific highschool n d it doesn't teach specifically forensics. For the common non-professional user, Quad9 can be a good upstream DNS provider. You don’t need to setup a Raspberry Pi and maintain a software up to date on your network. It was b/c of the Cloudfare outage. However, it takes forever for opendns to add a new site to block, so I am using Pi-Hole to block whatever opendns misses. conf says 1. In addition, as a second layer, you can also set the DNS resolver in pihole to Adblock DNS Family Protection or OpenDNS Family Shield ip adresses that are both free of charge. I use opendns as they have a free account where you can set up categories to block and of course it all goes through pihole locally first for caching and ad blocking. YouTube ads are a different beast. I see Pihole as a sword and NextDNS as a shield : Pihole ensures most annoyances are squashed without requiring much work, NextDNS ensures nothing nasty can go through. Currently I use PiHole on some of my VLANs and have been happy since I have more control. Why i think that? Coz i can observe and see the trafic of ip's while maltrail. Set it as the dns server for the wan connection to have the router use the pihole for its resolution. Normally I'd be running unbound locally but have been experimenting with the OpenDNS setup. Before using NextDNS for my LAN I was primaraly using a pihole. So double filtering essentially, Cloudflare denies the security stuff at the upstream, then pihole takes away the ad stuff. All devices on my LAN are set to use the pi as the only DNS server (192. But the best option is use one of these private DNS, but run a DNS server/cache either on the router or another server, like for example a NAS, and have that DNS use the private DNS as the source. Plus, it doesn’t just do DNS, it also can provide a DHCP server for your network too. Unless the site/add is ipv4 only. Permissible list formats for Pihole are domains or hosts. By using this DNS would it mess with the ad-blocking done by the Pihole, or would it work in conjunction with it. You have to use something like ddclient or OpenDNS Updater to notify them of your public IP address (or have a static one) and then you can apply category filters. So if you're using Cloudflare you would set the IPs (1. 220 and 208. Unbound does not do what pihole does. Hopefully this makes some sense. If you setup pihole and find a random machine still resolving through a different dns, try flushing I switched to AdGuard Home, but only because recent upgrades in the PiHole containers broke my PiHole really badly, and I didn't want to spend a bunch of time trying to fix it. DNS forwarder is enabled but Resolver is disabled in pfsense. 12K subscribers in the dns community. honestly, if you got docker running fine, i'd recommend keeping the dockerized version, since you can easily upgrade the hardware and deploy pihole again whenever you want and the container is not subject to any disasters such as hardware failures (due to age, power outage or whatever). Direct the pihole to forward to opendns upstream and get the best of both worlds. Can't say it made a difference either way. Hi. One goes down, no big deal. If privacy is important, its ad/track/spam/mal blocking via DNS is great. 100). And if your Pihole has secure passwords and doesn't run unsafe software, this isn't a big concern. 11) all together in Pihole as upstreams. OpenDNS is fed by the Talos Threat Intelligence team. Noob question: pihole blacklist files only work if they’re in following format 0. I preferred to use pihole finally. true. I verified traffic was being forwarded to OpenDNS, and in about 30 minutes, all inquiries to my Port 53 stopped. Also have you tried Adguard? I’m using pfblolcker now because, well the urge to tinker and break things. So I have been playing around with the luci app adblock on my travel router. conf does not replicate these addresses (i. First of all there is a pfsense community edition that is absolutely free. Pihole I am a new user to firewalla, and my experience with it has been mixed. In this way 1) I can use pihole, no matter the vlans clients are and 2) using unbound is avoiding pihole to use cloudflare/google/etc. With PiHole, any application on your PC (or other devices) will be subject to DNS blocking/filtering. The transmission speed of an rf signal down a wire vs through the air is different, but negligible in our frame of reference (few tenths of a ms per mile or dozen). I heard about Quad9 and CloudFlair and wanted to try them. I use both opendns, google, and L3 entries to spread my query history around. Pi-hole does great at blocking ads and such but the OpenDNS malware stuff is updated much more often and the categories blocking is handy. It's flawless and fast. OpenDNS will not be able to give you this. You get to take advantage of the same exact block lists without having to maintain a Linux box and PH's software, plus it has built in DNS Sec, HTTPS, and TLS which PH doesn't even support ootb. 0 abc. Jul 27, 2020 · PiHole's primary use is to use DNS blocklists to block ads from the network. com right? If the list doesn’t have 0. Edit: I do want to mention that performance benefits could be found depending on geographical location. One thing I really like in pihole is the locally resolved rdns names. since you mentioned Cloudflare ZT, I use both pihole plus Cloudflare ZT by just using the custom ZT Gateway DNS servers as the upstream DNS in Pihole. You can also pause PiHole blocking if needed quite simply, and without changing your DNS settings. It can setup a situation where, with Conditional Forwarding enabled, a loop develops that floods the local network as the PiHole and router keep routing device lookups back and forth to each other. g. Moving away from Untangle on Protectli FW4B due to the updated Untangle pricing structure. Pihole is on a static IP not dished out by my router. That seemed to work and coming back to the admin page for OpenDNS, and I traffic going through it which was great. pihole by itself offered little interest. Possibly the best is to install ddclient alongside pihole. About an hour later, I removed the forwarders (back to recursive) and about 30 minutes later, the queries are back. I currently run Pihole on my Rpi, and use Wireguard to connect to it on my phone and at the office. In order for this to work, your router has to be pointed at your PiHole for StaticDNS otherwise you're just bypassing the whole setup. 8 (Google DNS) Instead of any another DNS service. It's the Cyber patriot program. DuckDuckGo is a private alternative to Google search, as well as free browsers for mobile & desktop devices. Unbound first goes to the . . That said, no solution is pefect, and there's more configuration overhead with using both. opendns. Apr 9, 2018 · Sadly, despite being requested multiple times, OpenDNS Family shield does not provide this functionality – interestingly this seems like a fairly simple capability to offer considering that DNS itself is the mechanism to force Safe Search. I use Cisco Umbrella (formarly OpenDNS) for my upstream DNS. Save Either reboot your router or disconnect each client to renew the lease. 0. I think the best path to make sure the PiHole is working correctly is to fort just use it for a single device, say your laptop. xyz. NextDNS stands out for its ability to encrypt DNS queries, providing an additional layer of protection. Basically -- if you had a choice, you'd choose pihole. But devices/applications have always been free to ignore your suggested DNS and pick their own. With Adguard, I can have it using Google, Cloudfare, OpenDNS, etc all at once. Yes, I use OpenDNS in this way as my upstream DNS. This helps protect your overall privacy while surfing the we During the pi-hole installation, you select 1 of the 7 preset providers or enter one of your own. When i ping my router and pihole via wired device vs wifi device the latency is the same. I hope someone can figure this one out. This part is all working fine - when the OpenVPN client isn't running on the pi. OpenDNS is one of the choices, so you can use our solution with OpenDNS. Diversion is a great thing and does well for ads, but its missing a lot of the options and ease of administration that make pihole amazing. I am currently setting up my Pihole server, and I want to use OpenDNS Family Shield to block adult websites, so my teenager does not happen on them. The dns upstream of my Firewall is the IP of my pihole, and the upstream of my pihole is unbound, installed on the same rapsberry. some r trying malware, some r trying to exploit but more behevior has cloudflare dns. You could deploy either Pi-hole, or AdGuard Home. 3. but recently came across ControlD DNS. PiHole is simply the most popular, I'd say. If the DNS is known bad (and this is updated as Cisco/Talos identify sites as malicious), the lookup is blocked. Pi Hole on the other hand was easy to install, and works flawlessly but requires me to now either use it locally on my linux machine OR to setup a SEPERATE device, which while traveling isn't really a good option. Usually the Cyber Patriot program is for teaching highschoolers about Server administration and security but when we're not practicing for competition I'll ma This subreddit is a place where high income professionals of all types can ask, answer, discuss, and debate the personal finance and investing questions specific to our unique situations without being criticized, ostracized, or downvoted simply for having a high income and "first world" problems. The main benefit is that it's easier to use than the unbound blocklists and that it gives pretty graphs. I had no issue with NextDNS, was using for a year but like you I was curious about other providers. Unbound can be added to a pihole install to add that resolution method to how it does outside queries. The Pi-Hole dashboard began showing accurate per-client statistics, ad-blocking worked (pi-hole), smut-blocking worked (opendns), and DHCP clients can resolve both internal and external hostnames. Yes you can also do this in pihole but it's just another level of control. I am using opendns to block games, youtube, adult content, and other non-work categories. I followed his tutorial by using a Linux VM in Linode but of course when I powered the VM off my pihole server is gone. If you're looking for tech support, /r/Linux4Noobs and /r/linuxquestions are friendly communities that can help you. Then it asks those who is handling www. E. This means private DNS, but also devices on the local ne I used OpenDNS for a while and was pretty happy. Pihole configured to use pfsense via custom-options. Pihole only ever was able to act on DNS requests that were routed through it. Pfsense doesn’t pull through those well for a home user. I use this often right after i set up a fresh Pihole installation, it just saves some copy & pasting the URL's into the webinterface. Pihole keeps your DNS settings away from openwrt. This is definitely not a solicitation post :) I'm not affiliated with NextDNS or bad mouthing Pihole. Of course, these services apply to the whole household. Unbound stops this by only using the domain resolvers. I was unable to set it up in the router mode for the simple reason that ATT had given me a built in Fiber router and Wifi6 box. I had same question before. I take the worst offenders from my PiHole and block them there, this way when I temporarily disable blocking on the PiHole it’s not a free for all with things getting out. A better comparison for Opnsense would be pfsense with the pfblocker-devel package which offers the same if not better functionality, if you only need dns level blocking and you don't need anything else that either of them offer, use pihole plus it has pretty graphs I use OpenDNS because they allow you block 25 different domains. It allows some more generic filtering in addition to what I do with Pihole. Yes, hasn't been an issue. I went with ISC DHCP and BIND9 with RPZ since PiHole couldn't do more than one DHCP scope through the GUI at the time. They advertise themselves as free private DNS servers, but how do you know for certain they are keeping their promise that your information is truly private? Feb 14, 2022 · AdGuard DNS is a service similar to Cloudflare, Quad9, and OpenDNS among others which allows you to pass your web (DNS) requests to their servers. A subreddit for Christians of all sorts. This script would add just the ticked Firebog lists plus the advertising list from Developer Dan list to Pihole. Profit. Don't use providers because on my FiOS if you mess up the URL it will forward you to a Yahoo search results page for that URL. 1 Pi-hole is meant to block ads, trackers, malware, etc. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now to have a pihole, with variety of upstream DNS, to have local dnscrypt-proxy as an upstream, to have More important is how secure? Coz my experience shows cloudflare is fastest, quad9 fast opendns is most secure. ~ 5ms and ~12ms respectively. Pihole intelligently shifts between the fastest and most reliable of them. nilleftw July 7, 2022 at 3:35 AM. Most requests would be blocked by the pihole, but anything that gets through is blocked by these services. Any help or ideas would be greatly appreciated! Thanks! The upstream for pihole is my pfsense box. Unlike Chrome, DuckDuckGo browsers have privacy built-in with best-in-class tracker blocking that stop cookies & creepy ads that follow you around, & more. I must be missing something. and it's checking directly with the authoritative (forwarded to resolver2. That dashboard also has a community portal where other OpenDNS users discuss different domains and what they are. The added benefit is that these services promise a semblance of privacy and web security instead of the default DNS servers from your internet service provider (not-at-all secure or private). And that's what I'd recommend. Pihole does work great but is not an all-in-one solution, it cannot act as a DoT or DOH resolver nor forward queries through encrypted protocols without additional help with other tools. Our closest neighbors… Jan 16, 2024 · Final Thoughts on NextDNS vs Pihole In conclusion, both NextDNS and Pi-hole offer practical solutions to improve online security and privacy, but have significant differences. AdGuardHome vs Unbound Blacklist vs PiHole There are multiple solutions for DNS ad filtering when using OPNsense, and multiple ways of configuring those solutions--three big ones that I have seen. Firstly, thank you to all the people who develop and maintain pihole, what an amazing bit of software! I have pihole set up to use unbound with no forward resolvers, but over the past week (nothing prior) I've started seeing localhost resolver1. My issue is that I've got some travel coming up. I did some DNS performance testing and found no real difference between using unbound vs just referencing Cloudflare’s DNS servers. Jan 30, 2017 · I have set OpenDNS as primary DNS and Google (8. Opendns has lists as well as manual content filtering. However, looking at the admin page it seems that the Pi is simply using both at the same time. 67. Then once it is just point the entire Eero at the Pi for DNS. Reply reply Jun 9, 2018 · The concern with the existing method lies in step 4. EDIT. What is the advantage of Pi-hole vs just pointing my router to opendns for adblocking? Open DNS doesn't block ads and requires manual content filtering. In today’s world, these upstream servers are known as Google, OpenDNS, and CloudFlare, amongst others. This is a strange question. I'd recommend skipping the pihole step altogether and use NextDNS instead. Pfsense is a complete router replacement although you will still need a modem to get the internet into your house from AT&t, pfsense will take over all all the router duties as you will have your ISP put their router into bridged mode which will disable all but one ethernet port on the router. BACKGROUND: Doing a home router refresh. PiHole also gives you pretty graphs and reports on what is being blocked and from where. Start in the ReadMe, click on the desired list in the table of contents, normally it will then navigate to the description of the desired list. But never say never. Using both is way overboard for most home users. Been using it for over 15 years now and never had a problem. Those blocks made by opendns refer the user to a "site is blocked" page and I can whitelist them if needed. PiHole has a list of blocked domains that you can control. I've found that for me personally, the "filtering of harmful sites" sometimes interferes with my browsing habits (tends to happen if you frequent torrenting sites and the like, because they employ a very conservative view of what's "harmful"). Personally, I like CloudFlair 1. And you can manage it in one place. I eventually mothballed my pihole and just use NextDNS. 8. Disclaimer: I'm one of the Pi-Hole developers. I have disabled ipv6 on my network for similar reasons. As for Reddit and sites like that, DNS based solutions don't work, so I simply have uBlock installed. Great write up! Thank you. In Unbound, you set the upstream DNS servers in the DNS over TLS page. May 24, 2020 · At this time, the issue I'm facing is whether or not I properly Configured Parental Control, OpenDns and Pi-hole I was able to have the Pi-hole Ip as Dns, but once I activated the OpenDns the ip was replaced May 9, 2019 · I set the DNS servers on Luke and Beau to use OpenDNS forwarders of 208. However, Unbound does allow for more privacy and control (if you know what you are doing). I use OpenDNS as it offers both IP v4 and v6 filtered name servers. Disclaimer : I use Pihole with NextDNS as the resolver. Any of then aren't difficult to setup. I use both. It is a lot easier to manage and regardless of NextDNS itself being very vocal the blocklists are actively maintained and updated. hole, while accessing it with the ip works fine. is pihole's blocklist effective if pihole doesn't know what DNS is being queried. I will say this for PiHole, it handles local resolution in the UI much nicer. I dabbled with an AdGuard setup on a rpi but reverted back to the pihole. And I am not using opendns but cloudflare. Some r scanning vuln. 1) and hostname as cloudflare-dns. You can even run encrypted DNS-over-HTTPS. PiHole does not do anything there for you (AFAIK). Since the PiHole is managing the DNS, I'm not sure how to set up additional DNS rules on top of what the PiHole does. And ultimately gets the answer for the address for www. Enter Pi-Hole and dnsmasq. 168. 220. I use elements from both Pi-hole and AdGuard (AdGuard's dnsproxy, and Pi-hole's FTL, then Unbound+Redis, but I digress…). Thanks for the instruction! For some reason the destination NAT caused some big issues for me. I did check the setting where it uses OpenDNS but still nothing. 1. Say you visit www. 1, adguard dns/nextdns, & so on, wouldn't a local dns server still need to get it's updates from a remote one like google's or cloudflare's? & is unbound a local dns server or something else, just a cache or something? Pfsense DHCP is configured to use Pihole as DNS server. Point your laptop to use the pi for DNS and verify it's working, use the PiHole log to understand what's happening. Sure, there are a lot of advantages to using Pi-hole, the main one being that you absolutely don't have any control over what's getting blocked by AdGuard and what's not. The DHCP server on pfsense hands out the pihole IP address A NAT Port Forward rule created on the pfsense box to Redirect any DNS queries to pihole - following this link but substituting the IP ADMIN MOD • Control D (ControlD) vs Quad9 vs Cloudflare vs NextDNS vs OpenDNS Hello, I heard good things about Quad9 dns and Cloudflare service. As a test, I forwarded all of my internal queries (via Unbound) to OpenDNS. If pihole does not have a block rule, it forwards it back to unbound which has DHCP host information for local things and for WAN things it handles the DNS over TLS and DNSsec work. com resolvers and finds the addresses of the servers handling reddit. AdGuard Home isn't obvious where they are, and lists them under DNS Rewrites. Pihole is just set and forget. This means software you are free to modify and distribute, such as applications licensed under the GNU General Public License, BSD license, MIT license, Apache license, etc. This comes in handy every once in a while for Allow the PiHole IP to make DNS requests to the PfSense LAN IP. com#53) N/A (0. PiHole Setup. I fact, I would guess that having a “back-up” dns server set-up on your pihole will wind up degrading the functionality of unbound because unbound won’t be able to build-up its internal registry because the “backup” servers will undoubtedly respond faster initially then unbound will be able to when it has to reach out the first time I find that pihole does a better job, allows more control, and gives better feedback than just the built in ad blocker. I already have the PiHole set up using this guide. I have the DNS boxes checked for OpenDNS and everything. Which ip what to want to do. While all are great options and offer similar functionality I personally use Zenarmor coupled with ControlD on my OPNsense setup today. When I modify my DNS Upstream Servers (found on the Pi-hole's interface Settings > DNS > Upstream DNS Servers) and reboot my RPI, resolve. 15 from the pihole i loose connection to the internet and then have to bypass it to regain access to the internet. 39 votes, 43 comments. Assign my PiHole device a static IP on my AT&T router of 192. It is not even close to the same thing. And after a good time of using all 3 you could look at Piholes stats and see which ones have been used the most/least so far and maybe remove one. 1 and 8. Below you can find more information on each of the DNS providers, along with some additional providers which have different kinds of extra filtering options (spam, phishing, adult content, etc). So I used the video by NetworkChuck about setting this up. In this sense it's complementary to OPNSense. com and myip. my pihole is part of the dhcp settings from my router (currently using . After that I tried a few others Quad, OpenDNS and more but back to nextdns. But NextDNS technically stays an online third-party and as such there's a need to reduce traffic to what is really needed. , and software that isn’t designed to restrict you in any way. I don't get why people use 8. The only things I really hate re: ads are popups. It makes no sense for the router to hard-code cloudflare because cloudflare was not stable in where I bought the router. Personally, I have an OPNsense firewall/router, and it has a built in DNS with multiple blocklists you can choose from. Switch DNS server to manual and input the IP address of your pihole machine. 9. I have successfully installed and configured my pi-hole on my rpi-4. 1 which I use in PiHole in conjunction with ublockOrigin but thats just me. I've been running OpenDNS for a while and taking advantage of their Family Shield configuration. Router is pointed to Pihole for StaticDNS, Pihole is pointed as Cisco OpenDNS for it's upstream DNS. So I installed Pi-Hole and got it up and running (after a failed first install). TBH, Umbrella is an excellent first line of defense. as its upstream dns, and it's checking directly with the authoritative I've virtualized as well as run PiHole on a rasp pi. You could use Google, OpenDNS and Quad9 (9. ) as the secondary one in PiHole. reddit. For example, I was using Cloudfare at one point on Pihole and they had an outage. Pihole seems to be working, every request is being routed by the rpi. My firewall is blocking them all. 112-253 Turn off ipv6 everywhere (AT&T router, my computer, PiHole) Reboot AT&T router and PiHole The issue I had, and maybe keepalived is better, is that pihole was still up and running (receiving pings) but it wasn't giving out dhcp IP's or resolving DNS lookups so kemp didn't stop directing traffic to that pihole. When I enable ipv6 and pihole, my blocking is degraded in such a way that it almost doesn’t work. Set the pihole dns in the dhcp settings for your network to have devices on that network use the pihole for dns. 4. I can ignore ads generally and some are making them so damn annoying because of what pihole and the likes avoids. I absolutely love Pihole and how much I've customized it. NextDNS it's the easier, just create an account, choose some security settings and blocklists, then follow the instructions on the first page, however it has a query limit per mouth. OpenDNS is cool, cloudflare is fine. So it does not appear to be opendns issue but rather how pihole works on ipv6. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit pihole cache vs. Any help much appreciated! I'm sorry if this has been addressed; I've read through lots of discussions but still haven't come away with a clear answer. 111 Turn off my AT&T Router DHCP Turn on my PiHole DHCP Set the PiHole Gateway to 192. I stopped using pihole when the white list became unreliable. I hope this helps somebody in the future! Yes, with a nuance : pihole is the dns server and will block the domains ads are coming from, rather than specific servers For example, doubleclick (google's platform) will be unreachable, buy youtube will still load video ads because they host videos [citation needed] that users want to watch [dubious claim - clarify] Crossposting to r/Adguard, r/OPNsenseFirewall, and r/pihole…. In this way 1) I think I can use pihole, no matter in which vlans the clients are and 2) using unbound is avoiding pihole to use cloudflare/google/etc. The packets seems to have been forwarded just fine because both Pi-Hole and OpenDNS got the DNS requests, but nothing actually returned to the client I couldn’t browse the Internet. The overlap would be in the ‘cool block lists’. The key is static IP for PiHole. OpenDNS 1 OpenDNS 2 Read an interesting post on reddit regarding the randomness of which DNS entry in the router is used by the client and it is interesting to see that the 'second' DNS entry is getting more traffic that the first. xckw zjpc hyty xmdyb vtitf cplhv mqgp tokxsq gvjsv abutj ujwks brjo yzniiot lpfuhe laskn