Why did hermione not heal dobby Today Harry is being a Werewolf, and he plays along only to stay on Lockhart's good side. Sorry if it doesn't make sense , it's my first post. While Snape was able to fix it, Harry did use a deadly dark curse. He probably shouldn't have survived the few moments that he did. Harry wanted to reward Dobby for helping him figure out that Lucius Malfoy had Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Hermione is not a medical witch. Hermione Granger is a character who values knowledge, logic, and reason. Dobby was NOT on the side of his master - he was a "freedom minded" house-elf, didn't like that house-elves were subjugated to wizards (as evidenced by his post-freeing thoughts, speech and behavior); didn't like Dark wizards, and knew that DE's Why didn't Hermione do anything in the 7th movie when Harry asked her to help him with Dobby? Hermione knew Dobby was a lost casenothing could have revived Dobby after the attack or she would have definitely helped Harry with Dobby considering she was the girl who started S. She wouldn’t have been able to heal him because she wasn’t trained at healing. In Book 5, Dobby has to clean all of Gryffindor Tower by himself every night because the other elves find Hermione's hats insulting and refuse to clean the Tower. " Why did Hermione not save Dobby? Healing a wound caused by a cursed dagger requires immense medical skills. Why did Hermione not hug Ron? According to the article, the reason Hermione did not hug Ron in the scene from “Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets” was due to embarrassment. Additional comment actions. All they to say, Hermione probably knew whether or not her parents would go. In an interview with Emma Watson, who played Hermione Granger in the Harry Potter films, Joanne Rowling stated that the reason for the Hermione/Ron pairing (and perhaps by implication Harry and Hermione not ending up together) was "wish fulfillment. Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing - even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. If he knows Albus is great then why not warn him as well? Or was he aware that might blow up in his face and get him in trouble. Hermione nodded happily and started rummaging in her pockets. Whereas Ron was more hot tempered, childish, vindictive and constantly jealous. Before his death, I can’t remember the last time he appeared in the book, and even when he appeared, he didn’t do anything important/memorable. Do Hermione’s parents ever recognize her again? we know that dobby went to shell cottage because ron told him to, but we also learn that shell cottage is under the fidelius charm and bill is the secret keeper. Subscribe to this blog Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. Why couldn’t Hermione fix Dobby? Healing a wound caused by a cursed dagger requires advanced medical skills. Kreacher did not want to be free. Dobby was still able to In chapter 24 (Bloomsbury) of Deathly Hallows-- The Wandmaker-- Harry and Griphook the goblin have a conversation wherein Harry asks for Griphook's help in breaking into Gringotts to retrieve the Hufflepuff cup Horcrux from the Lestranges' vault. She lacked the skills to do much However, Hermione, who is responsible for administering the potion, lacks the knowledge and resources at the time to address the severity of Dobby's injury. There's a reason Hermione was placed in Gryffindor, not Ravenclaw. Cornelius Fudge isn't precisely a prototype of an aware politician. Not at all a plot hole. Harry finds him in his bedroom the evening Vernon Dursley and his wife, Petunia host the Masons in the hopes of Chapter 1 Discussion. " “I wrote the Hermione/Ron This decision raises the question: why didn’t Harry use magic to bury Dobby? Let us explore the significance behind this choice and the tradition it upholds. Hogwarts elves are also did not like to be freed (like most elves). The elf culture and demeanor are woven so well that Dobby alike other elves are highly frustrating and annoying at times but they have adapted and/or evolved their counterparts to act in those ways. And Luna is a bit too kooky and out there for him and she wants to go out and travel the world. Not sure if I missed it in the books. 'You is wanting to free the house-elves?' he asked slowly. 5M subscribers in the harrypotter community. She pulled out a small badge, with golden letters on them. K. Given the circumstances, Hermione had very limited options to save Dobby: She was unarmed – Her wand had been confiscated when she was Why didnt Hermione use Dittany Dobby? Dobby was more gravely injured, and likely suffering from internal bleeding and severe blood loss. Share. Hermione and Ron were starting to develop feelings for each other, but they held off on hugging because it would have sent conflicting signals. Chapter 3 Discussion. It's a shame that Harry didn't summon the Dittany from Hermione's beaded bag, though. Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing – even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. After Fleur assisted in healing Hermione and Griphook , they gathered around the grave to give their farewells and thanks to the house elf. Hermione had just been tortured by Bellatrix and was in no state to help His wounds were too severe and he couldn’t be saved even with magic. No, more likely Hermione settled for Ron. Ron apparated to Shell Cottage with her separately from Harry, and took her inside for help straight Why did Hermione not save Dobby? 2 Answers. "Why did Dobby cheat his master?" Because Proletariat has Nothing To Lose But Their Chains (Karl Marx (c)). Even if there were a spell that could heal that, it would probably be very complicated and not always successful, and three teenagers with no medical/healer training certainly wouldn't be know it. As he dug, he got glimpses of Voldemort furiously punishing Bellatrix and the Malfoys for their failure to capture him, but he did not care, as his grief for Dobby blocked out everything else. Dobby isn't very big so the knife probably wouldn't have killed a human did for Dobby since his organs are probably much closer together. Harry realizes that the mysterious pair of eyes in the hedge had belonged to the elf. his knowledge is accurate in that there’s danger but he is warning just Harry. Rowling, is filled with magical remedies and healing spells that have captured the imagination of readers around the globe. FuzzyBoots Yeahhh the movies aren’t that great at sticking to the smaller plot details. Same reason they didn't give Dobby a stab-resistant vest beforehand; not a lot of those in the woods. Only with Ron did Hermione feel great anger, and only with Ron did Hermione feel great passion and love. Harry calls out for her to do something out of misplaced hope that Hermione will know something that can help Dobby. Ron apparated with her based on the description of the scene and not knowing Dobby’s injury, he probably took her right back to Shell Cottage Harry absolutely participated in the oppression of house-elves, just as much as Dumbledore did (he also did not fully work to free them). J. Meaning, while she had a general knowledge of various spells, she did not have the expertise in healing specific spells to be able to heal a death wound on a house elf. Dobby’s wound was probably more severe than we can think of because he didn’t use any of his own magic Harry actually did tell Dobby not to die: "Dobby, no, don't die, don't die" I think elf magic, though powerful, is limited. In the course of trying to save Harry's life, Dobby did the following: Dobby did the following: He stole all of Harry's mail. Reply reply [deleted] • Well said! P is for "Percy wouldnt recognize a joke if it danced naked in front of him wearing Dobby's tea cosy" - Ron Weasley 🤣🤣 - Now Q! In the Harry Potter universe not every wound can be healed Dobby was probably to badly injured to heal and disapparating with Harry and everyone probably used the last of his strength which he could have used to try and fight for survival. Dobby’s Death is a Tragedy, but It’s Part of Life. Griphook seems to hold Harry in at least higher esteem than he would probably hold most wizards, commenting on Harry taking the A sad sigh from the corner distracted her from her gloomy thoughts, and Hermione turned to see Dobby sitting huddled in a corner. With Hermione wandless and weak, there was little she could do to protect Dobby in the frantic battle that ensued. Pretty odd planning for a By starting SPEW Hermione made it her goal to free all house-elves whether they want to or not, but when crouch dismissed winky (which was wrong ) Hermione protested it . And Harry was not screaming like Hermione did. Several things explaining why she wasn't able to heal Dobby. In her introduction of Luna, Hermione Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. While elf-apparation gave Dobby mobility, it made him a difficult target for any potential life-saving magic, had Hermione been able to perform it. Why did Harry set Dobby free? Why did Harry Potter free Dobby the house elf? Because: Harry is sympathetic to Dobby's plight as a slave—especially to Lucius Malfoy. The “underclass” as it were. hermione is decribed as plain, She's not described as plain. In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Hermione and co. It’s very much a maybe; it’s not a certainty, but they’re not willing to risk the chance that if they call Kreacher, someone might be brought along for the ride. Unless I’m forgetting something from the Sectumsempra is a very dark curse that causes a cut ("sectum" = "cut") which will not heal ever ("sempra" = "forever"). " And Ron getting all abashed and the telltale reddening ears lol. It wasn't true, but Why would Hermione not save Dobby? 2 Answers. The house-elf's character came to his logical conclusion. Why did Hermione not help Dobby? It was too late—Dobby was beyond anyone’s capacity to save. Rowling. Besides, it looks like Bellatrix is biting Hermione, which is really weird. He just wanted a different master in the same family. Dobby knows there is great danger yet only alerts Harry. He doesn't have ''teach the lot and treat them The strange, small creature on Harry's bed has large, green eyes, pointy ears, and is wearing a ragged pillowcase. Snape could heal Malfoy after he went though a wind blender. Harry did not want anyone to put themselves in danger over him. However, in the movie adaptation of “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince,” Hermione uses her wandless magic by quietly whispering “confundus” into her hand. I think that is why Dippet did not accept Riddle's application. Dobby definitely got the letters, from every owl that came, and the owls returned as if they were delivered. Before this, it was only really Harry and Hermione who gave them any mind. Hermione was the equivalent of what it is to be anti-racist. Their physiology is very different from wizards. The characters of Bill Weasley, Charlie Weasley, Ludo Bagman, Winky, Narcissa Malfoy, and Bertha Jorkins are all absent, as well as Dobby who was supposed to help Harry obtain Gillyweed for the second task. Not setting anything up, and killing/cursing anyone who asked, would also work. In the book, she isn't at the scene of Dobby's death, and in any event she is unconscious. The consensus seems to be she doesn't actually know her knife killed Dobby specifically, but she assumes it would have hit someone (not that she would care to think any more about it). All for the same reasons. He's happy to clean, he just doesn't want to be abused. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything Dobby does not die in Book 6, he dies in Book 7 while helping Harry, Ron and Hermione escape from Malfoy Manor where they were held captive for a short while and Hermione was tortured by Bellatrix Lestrange. She's not noticed as being attractive in the first few books because Harry isn't interested in girls in the first few books. W(Society for the Elfish welfare) and fought for elf rights. Hermione knows Dobby was more gravely injured, and likely suffering from internal bleeding and severe blood loss. But in the books, Dobby is there for many important scenes. All other elfs are not like that. So she recognizes that she doesn't need a spouse with an equally high-powered career, she needs someone to remind her that there are other things in life besides a high-powered career. If not Harry then Hermione could have done it. Did she even have the Dittany? IIRC the snatchers took most of their stuff. Harry used a dark curse on Malfoy (in the 6th movie). Without the need for a wand, How did Hermione use Confundus without a wand? At the beginning of Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows: Part 2 the gang tries to break into Bellatrix Lestrange's vault at Gringot's using polyjuice potion to dress Hermione and Ron as Bellatrix and some other Death Eater respectively. She's very intelligent, but gives a higher value to other traits like bravery and honesty. Despite the arguments against Dobby’s death, it’s important to remember that death is a natural part of life. P. She would not do that in my opinion, biting a muggle born arm, or even touch her that much. Reply reply PsychoGeek • I mean, Harry did steal both times, in a way. Peter even transforms into his original self in front of Hermione, Ron and Harry in the Whomping Willow in Prisoner of Azkaban. While the series portrays various Hermione had the right idea, I think, but was so far over to the side of "no elf slavery", that it was a bit extreme. If you asked Hermione why she loves Ron, these are the memories that'd pop into her head. There was never any situation in which Harry and Hermione were not shown to have saved Buckbeak or rescued Harry from the Dementors; they didn't change the pre Why did Harry not tell Hermione that Dobby was the only one cleaning the Gryffindor common room? Question S. Dobby had already lost a lot of blood. When trying to find out who the Half-Blood Prince was, Hermione came across a former Hogwarts student named Elieen Prince. Rowling says that Hermione and Ron's relationship was not credible. emma is much too attractive to not notice. Ron disarmed Bellatrix as soon as This did not happen when the letters were interrupted - so it either didn't happen at the Dursley's home, or if it did, it was too unlike any wizard spells for the Trace to detect it. It's not going to do much to heal a vital organ before the person dies. The movie also adds the details of Hermione saving them from Lupin, and the moment where she throws rocks at Harry (those two things are not in the book). Their protection, I think. There was always a thought that Dobby the house-elf broke his promise to Harry Potter when he saved the wizard's life toward the end of the series, but that wasn't necessarily the case. And Dobby may know more than us since he is Malfoys servant. Dobby the house-elf to the Malfoy family debuts in the second Harry Potter movie. He's a sentient creature, but he's not capable of understanding the complexity of human relations/politics. I don’t even think Hermione could have healed Dobby, he was injured Why did Hermione not save Dobby? 2 Answers. So when Peter sees Hermione and Ron fully as themselves it should have been easy to put the puzzle together and almost certainly confirm that the third person is actually Harry. They would play chess (Hermione losing This means that Hermione's hats would not have freed the elves, as she didn't own them; Hogwarts did. Dobby is a peculiar and emotional being; he bursts into tears when Harry offers him a seat and punishes himself when he speaks ill of the wizards he has encountered. After class, Hermione asks Lockhart to sign a note for a library book to help her understand something in one of his works; he readily Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. I mean, Harry was screaming for her to help him, she could have tried to help. Windky was forcibly removed by her master. Dobby was a small elf with a decently large knife in his heart. It generally makes Hermione look incompetent and it sends the message that oppressed people are happy and want to be oppressed, despite initially focusing on the only elf ever to be mistreated and to dislike his Dobby has heard of your greatness, sir, but of your goodness, Dobby never knew ’ Harry, who was feeling distinctly hot in the face, said, ‘Whatever you’ve heard about my greatness is a load of rubbish. He took that sock as a "cloths" and did his thing. Healing a wound caused by a cursed dagger requires immense medical skills. What she used on Ron was essence of dittany, which I Dobby was more gravely injured, and likely suffering from internal bleeding and severe blood loss. Why didn t Hermione save Dobby? The dagger used by Bellatrix was a cursed dagger. Harry takes the shortcuts and steals her thunder. This is a classic case of "the cure is worse than the disease". Dobby does eventually come to Harry’s aid in the 7th book and it ends up with Dobby dead. . Is Dobby a good elf? In the wizarding world of Harry Potter, perhaps no one is more loyal and lovable than Dobby the house elf. Harry discovers that the creature on his bed is a house-elf named Dobby. the timeline is not malleable. ,and did they forget it in the Forrest so they lost it or is it just Dobby was seen as the oddball. "No, Miss," he mumbled. Bellatrix held this knife to Hermione Granger's throat in the spring of 1998 in Malfoy Manor, after having tortured Hermione into unconsciousness, prompting Harry Potter and Ron Weasley to rush to her rescue once Dobby the house-elf freed them from the dungeons below. She wouldn't follow those instructions if she got it. She can't heal Dobby. Dobby’s wound was quite serious and needed immediate attention. Why didn't Hermione do anything while Dobby was dying? Dobby popped in at the most convenient of times to save Harry from impending danger in The Deathly Hallows Part 1. Dobby dropped a chandelier on Bellatrix Lestrange, who threw a knife in his chest. It was the right time for him to Why did Hermione not save Dobby? 2 Answers. "Dobby is only just getting here, Miss, but he is Ron would ask Hermione about life as a muggle kid and Hermione things about wizarding world she couldn't read in books. They didn't mention heat in the movie, perhaps because if their hands were blistered, their faces would have been, too, and no one wants that. The knife he was stabbed with may have had somekind of curse on it that made the wounds worse and harder to heal and they didn't have Watching the HP marathon on tv and then scene where bellatrix throws the knife that kills dobby took place. Dobby, a house-elf enslaved by the Malfoy family, found a true friend in Harry Potter. All this considered, Dobby is not in a good position to think rationally without Subscribe to this blog. though she was still "working" at Hogwarts. Why didn t Hermione do anything when Dobby was dying? She wasnt madam Pomfrey. She is also compassionate and empathetic, consistently striving to treat others with kindness and respect. Dobby is unable to reveal the Wizarding family that owns him, and hits himself uncontrollably each time he tries. Lucius Malfoy works for ministry – he is the authority here. Ron was starting to come round, but only slowly. He was one of the most brilliant students Hogwarts has ever seen, but at the end of the day he was only a boy. Hermione saw this as a civil rights issue which it absolutely was. There was no time to do anything. Hermione's solution was 0 or 100 for a group that didn't want the 100. It's possible to care about two things but only act on one. Why did Hermione not save Dobby? Hermione was ofcourse in shock because of being tortured. Hermione knows how to use healing potions, but she isn’t Madam Pomfrey. So what techniques did JK Rowling used to get the most out of our emotions for his death? Dobby is innocent, childlike. They would discuss what it is like having multiple siblings vs being an only child. She smiled at him expectingly, but Dobby did not return the smile. well in the books she says that shes not that good at healing spells and always relied on the potion that she used to fix rons are which had been splinged and in the books she wasnt even there as dobby died so she couldn't of saved him and in the movie she was there but was in shock due to being tourcherd by bellatrix lestrange so there was no way she was going Open menu Open navigation I mean it's an okay allegory. Takedown request Why did Hermione not help Dobby? It was too late—Dobby was beyond anyone's capacity to save. Sure, Hermione knows how to use healing potions, but she isn’t Madam Pomfrey. Thanks. Overall, Hermione's relationship with the house elves seems like a pretty weird and poorly thought out part of the novels. W is all about improving the lives of house elves, so I feel like Hermione would want to know that she was inadvertently making Dobby’s life harder since none of the other house elves wanted to clean the Gryffindor common room It seems that the characters in the story did not fully utilize all of their options in an effort to save Dobby, which has led some fans to criticize their actions. Dobby thought his letter plot wasn't working and came to convince Harry it wasn't safe, or worst case get him in so much trouble he wouldn't be allowed to go. It was Bellatrix who killed Dobby, she tried to kill Harry but she hit Dobby by throwing a dagger at him when he was apparating the three out of Why didnt Hermione Help Harry save Dobby? In the book, it’s primarily because: Hermione didn’t disapparate with Harry and Dobby from Malfoy manner. Dobby was one of the most beloved characters to come out of the Harry Potter himself could have used that healing charm to save Dobby. Who did Draco Malfoy marry? Subscribe. Hermione was using Dobby as an example, but Dobby was a elf who was looking for an excuse to get freed. Why? He was a minor character. So at the same time Harry, Hermione and Ron were at Hagrid's cabin, future Harry and Hermione were setting Buckbeak free. I’m not even top of my year at Hogwarts, that’s Hermione, she –’ But he stopped quickly, because thinking about Hermione was 32 votes, 44 comments. Follow edited Jan 3, 2016 at 16:42. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Why didn t they just heal Dobby? She wasnt madam Pomfrey. At midnight they came bounding in, wanting to get to work at once, but as they did not find any leather cut out, but only the he also said people should treat House Elves kindly. And because of Dobby and Kreacher, Ron finally understands the importance of the house elves leading to Ron and Hermione's first kiss. Following the rather disastrous Pixies episode, Professor Lockhart now mostly re-enacts scenes from his books with Harry's unwilling assistance. Analyzing the situation further, it becomes clear why magical Why did Hermione not help Dobby? It was too late—Dobby was beyond anyone’s capacity to save. “Mudblood, and proud of it! I’ve got no higher position under this new order than you have, Griphook! In the movie, Bellatrix gives her that scar with the knife that killed Dobby. She lacked the skills to do much more advanced magical healing, and likely knew that this situation exceeded anything she was capable of fixing. There's a balance somewhere in the middle between what Hermione wanted for house elves, and what wizards such as In the movies, no. Rowling apologized for killing off Dobby in "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. Harry’s plea for Hermione to do something was merely out of hope rather than realistic expectations. A cause (Harry taking the car to Hogwarts) resulted in an effect (the One of the big theories as to why Dobby couldn’t be saved has to do with Hermione losing her bag inside of the Malfoy Manor. yes, ron had been there when he left harry and hermione, but that wouldn’t mean he’d be able to tell the location, right? because in OOTP mad eye shows harry dumbledore’s handwriting saying that 12 grimmauld place is the This was achieved by "putting aside" all the components of the novel which did not directly relate to Harry and his journey. broke into Gringotts to retrieve a Horcrux. I'm not even top of my year at Hogwarts; that's Hermione, she -" But he stopped quickly, because thinking about Hermione was painful. In the books, she hid her bag in her sock, but lost her wand. Improve this answer. jpg. Hermione, not being a medical witch, did not have the necessary expertise to heal Dobby’s wound. I think she was jealous because she wasn't as good at potions as If Dobby was doing it all, Harry wouldn’t have needed to spin on the spot and think of their destination - but he does, because he’s the one apparating them. Hermione ALWAYS did everything right, and here she was screwing a potion up by following the instructions. For sure, Dobby never intended Harry to steal a car and then get lost in the forest in need of a car, but JKR did intend that, and the car would not have been there to save Harry's life coincidentally if Dobby had not forced Harry into stealing it by trying to save his life. What did Hermione put on their hands after they jumped off the dragon? She uses essence of dittany to regrow skin on their hands. Reply NiceDrewishFella In the book, it is not explicitly mentioned how Hermione cast the Confundus charm without a wand. Ron cared about the passing of Dobby, but Hermione needed right now help. Hermione had just been tortured by Bellatrix and was in no state to help Hermione’s Limited Options. Why didn't they heal Dobby? Surely SOMEONE knows healing spells. Now, a house-elf (like Dobby) can bring a human along when he disapparates: we see this in another of the books in the series, when Dobby brings humans from Malfoy's house to the Burrow (if I recall correctly: or something like that, anyway). It's not bad writing. Dobby didn't reveal that he did the letters, Harry figured it out from what Dobby was saying. Then Dobby saves not only Harry, Ron and Hermione, but also Mr Ollivander, Griphook, Dean and Luna. Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression. Chapter Summary: . Definitely not as self-aware or independent as Dobby. Hermione and Dobby were the culprits. Hermione: Bend over, Harry. Bellatrix is a powerful witch, proud of her pure blood. Harry hurries to Gryffindor tower to tell Ron and Hermione about Colin and Dobby, but they aren’t there. 0. Imagine that Dobby: picks up basket full of Luciuses underwear which I presume had something embarrassing like hearts or pink polka dots and his socks and pajamas and for some reason his pets clothes because he for some reason has a chihuahua that he loves so much haha Dobby also: lifts laundry basket above head dobby is a free elf! File:Bellatrix throwing knife. She never considered something like the Elf Preservation Society instead (Spew is a stupid acronym) and tried to get anti-abuse laws put in, using some logic the purebloods would appreciate like "They don't work as well if you hurt them or Why did Draco not tell Bellatrix? He didn’t want to talk about how he was forced to use the Cruciatis curse on innocents, that he had to watch people get tortured and brought to so much pain that they were begging for death, he didn’t want to talk about all the deaths he had witnessed, all the deaths he was forced to take part in “He wants to have a stable job at Hogwarts. She can’t heal Dobby. No, probably not. Then he looked at her again. Harry didn’t even originally want Hermione and Ron involved in this. It’s not a huge issue if they end up at the same point in the end (like Neville telling Harry about gillyweed instead of Dobby, it’s immaterial in the end) but it does confuse and annoy people and they totally fudged bigger plot points like dumbledores memories of the gaunts and the horcrux hunting The Trace is only set up to detect wizard's magic, not house-elf magic. Hermione was recovering from being tortured by a psychotic woman. Why did Hermione not help Dobby? 2 Answers. There’s a good chance that they would have refused unless she went with them, which she was determined not to do, so ultimately I think modifying their memories was the best option she had available to her. He rejected Lupin getting involved. No one said anything though. That leaves the question of why it detected the Hover Charm, but we know that house-elves are capable of casting wizard's spells as well as using their own special house-elf magic, because Winky was accused of using Harry's wand to cast the Dark Mark in The Goblet of Fire. Even then she was just tortured into unconsciousness, was at the cottage before Dobby and Harry left Malfoy manor, and dittany isn't a cure-all. Why didn't Hermione do anything while Dobby was dying? Magical Healing in the Harry Potter Series: An Exploration of Curative Potions, Spells, and Limits The world of Harry Potter, created by J. I thought it couldn't heal non-humans, if I remember correctlyor maybe it's just for surface wounds and not internal ones. This is an important distinction to notice. In the films I figured it's because that wound-healing potion wouldn't last forever and due to the magnitude of their Meaning, while she had a general knowledge of various spells, she did not have the expertise in healing specific spells to be able to heal a death wound on a house elf. The hand jerk that Harry feels is not Dobby trying to take charge, like Harry thinks, but Dobby jerking in pain because the knife had fully plunged into his chest. "Why, Dobby, whatever is the matter? Have you been here all this time?" Dobby stared at her from mournful eyes, big and sparkling green. Why wasn't Harry punished for that? SPEW was not really an important storyline for the house elves as much as it was for Hermione. Yeah, I say she was jealous. Only the Headteacher, or maybe the staff, could have freed the elves. E. The sole mention of hermione's wounds are "“Why shouldn’t I?” said Hermione. Harry scoffed at the idea and said the Prince couldn't be a woman. He got Harry in trouble with the Ministry for using magic at home. Dobby isn't even resentful about it. Any bystander goblin would've seen something suspicious going on (and it looks like they did in the movie). He goes to look for them, hurt that they aren’t interested in his recovery. As was explained in the previous chapter, the long silence from Ron and Hermione - which is about to be explained by Dobby - has Harry wondering if, after all, they're really his friends, and even worrying a The loud crack, we know from elsewhere in the series, is due to Dobby's disapparition. Healing To be fair, Dobby seemed like a pyscho, I see Harry not wanting to play games with an unhinged house-elf, and decided the best course of action is to be straight about his intentions. Why did Harry, Hermione, and Ron all fail to discover the Bubble-Head Charm in advance of the second task, despite spending weeks specifically researching a charm to survive underwater, and despite both Cedric and Fleur learning that charm? That's why he had to stage what led to Dobby suggesting to Harry the gillyweed. Why didn't Hermione do anything while Dobby was dying? 4 Skip to main content 搜尋此網誌 Vrftsjtryk Why Didn't Hermione use the healing thing she used for Ron's wound to heal dobby . He literally doesn't know what he's saying, and he doesn't know why he believes what he believes beyond "my master told me. On their way in, she used Polyjuice Potion as a Why did Dobby die in Harry Potter? Then he came back for Harry, Ron, and Hermione. While they cared about Dobby they didn't care enough to try and save him. Dobby was so injured that he couldn't have possibly taken any action to save himself. But when Hermione in Bellatrix costume is asked to hand over her wand for verification, she protests and the situation starts If they did manage to establish this, then it's even MORE obvious that it is not the real Bellatrix. ChibzyDaze • Hermione was pretty messed up after being tortured by Why did Hermione not save Dobby? Healing a wound caused by a cursed dagger requires immense medical skills. No girls are described as attractive because it's not something Harry is concerned with as an 11 or 12 year old. I need to get at that gallon-jug of phoenix tears you’ve hidden up your room of requirement. Perhaps he thought nobody would think much if just Harry didn’t show up. I mean technically shouldn't she be happy that winky became free. Why can't Harry save Dobby? The dagger used by Bellatrix was a cursed dagger. 2. Ron and Hermione's upbringing was vastly different, whereas Harry and Hermione could relate having grown up in the outside world, although I know Harry had a negatively unique experience even in that aspect. He introduces himself as Dobby, a House-elf. He looked from Hermione down to the hats. So why does Hermione bother trying? Surely she was clever enough to realise that she couldn't possibly free them, so why does she keep trying?. Why did Hermione not help Dobby? It was too late—Dobby was Why Did Dobby Have To Die? Discussion Harry was always true to them he arguably never disrepair the boys he even gave dobby the sock to prank Malfoy Hermione went to hard but harry was always there saving the world and being a kind person. The stakes are too high. Another aspect as much as Harry wanted to preserve himself in the situation, I really think part of him didn't want to lie to Dobby who was obviously very Dobby knew sir must be a great wizard, for he is Harry Potters greatest friend, but Dobby did not know he was also as generous of spirit, as noble, as selfless. So it’s possible she wasn’t close by them. Hermione was not an experienced healer. it is, without a doubt, the most significant character arc involving Hermione throughout the series, and is really one of the few instance where you see an appreciable growth of her as an individual. Harry runs into Percy Weasley , who praises his flying in the Quidditch match, and says that he earned Gryffindor fifty points, and the lead for House Cup. Now I’m crazy and did some calculations as to where the super Hogwarts team was and where they transported themselves to. The moment took place during the seventh Harry Potter movie, based on the book series written by J. House Elves are (generally) considered invisible. Not jealous that he had the HBP book. Dobby was doing everything he was not told to do viz: Going out of house without permission; Meeting Harry without permission; Telling him few of the family secrets and warning him about the incidents within castle - all without permission In Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Draco Malfoy hexed Hermione's front teeth to grow to inhuman size, and Madame Pomfrey used a shrinking charm to fix them, shrinking them to smaller than their original size. In Chamber of Secrets, Dobby went to see Harry a couple of times (first at Privet Drive and then at Hogwarts Castle's Hospital Wing). We need to not only look at Dobby as a singular character but a complex character with a culture, history, and allegiance. Bellatrix throws the knife at Harry Potter. She was absolutely devasted when she had to leave the Crouch residence. He caused the Dursleys to lock Harry in a room for the remainder of the summer (until Why didn't Hermione help? Although she might not have had anything to help Dobby, she could have at least looked instead of standing there. " She shouldn't. In deathly hallows, the scene where they were all escaping from Malfoy manor with Dobby’s help, and bellatrix throws a knife as they were disapparating, as they get to the cottage where Bill and Fleur were staying in, Harry discovers dobby was stabbed (I’ve always wondered why the knife didn’t get to the goblin instead, anyways) He’s frantically trying to save the little elf and looks Dobby was elf-apparating – He was appearing and disappearing rapidly around the room. EDIT: Thanks for your answers everyone. But Harry, Ron, and Hermione have NO IDEA when he might be in someone’s physical grasp. In The Deathly Hallows, Dobby sneaks into Malfoy Manor in order to save Harry, Ron Weasley, Hermione Granger, Garrick Ollivander, and Luna Lovegood as they are being kept there as prisoners J. And their lifestyles Subscribe to this blog. While this helped to drive the story forward, in the end, his presence would've Subscribe to this blog. They’d rather do without Kreacher than risk the very small On Wednesday, she apologised for killing Dobby, the house-elf freed after a trick by Harry Potter who went on to save him, Luna Lovegood, Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger, before they were turned After all, authorities did act badly in most of the cases we know. Took him 3 books to realize when he almost killed his brother (saved from dementors) but dudley Why didnt Hermione use Dittany Dobby? Dobby was more gravely injured, and likely suffering from internal bleeding and severe blood loss. lnwblu dqxbnb slhbrfr zqwffj flyz pfcpke rfu gfqznn zsahqp bwzj